Invasion of Privacy vs. E-Commerce: Retailers Face Off Against Privacy Rights Groups In California

Internet Lawyer Privacy Lawyer

On Wednesday, the California Supreme Court will hear oral arguments in Apple v. Krescent, a case which pits e-commerce giants against consumer rights and invasion of privacy advocates over whether the Song-Beverly Act, enacted in 1991, applies to Internet transactions. The Song-Beverly Act, a California state statute, places limits on the personal information that can be collected from a credit card owner during a transaction and states that a retailer cannot:

  1. Request that the cardholder write personal information on the credit card transaction form;
  2. Condition a credit card transaction upon a request that the retailer list the personal information of the purchaser on the credit card transaction form; or
  3. Utilize a pre-printed form that contains spaces for the purchaser to include his or her personal information.

E-commerce retailers, in this case Apple, argue that their collection and use of personal information prevents against fraud and that, if the statute is applied to the Internet, fraud will be increased. In contrast, consumer rights groups argue that their collection and use of personal information is for marketing purposes. This case is not without precedent, however, as in 2011 Williams and Sonoma was was found liable for violating the Act because it collected zip codes, which the Court ruled was unnecessary to prevent against fraud.

 

If e-commerce retailers are prevented from collecting this information, it may result in a substantial change in the way that retailers do business online. Revision Legal will continue to watch this area of law as it develops and will advise our e-commerce clients accordingly.

Extra, Extra!
Recent Posts

Worrying About SaaS Agreements and Cross-Border Data Transfers

Worrying About SaaS Agreements and Cross-Border Data Transfers

Internet Law

When your business is contemplating a software-as-a-service (“SaaS”) agreement, there are a large number of considerations. An SaaS agreement is, of course, a subscription service where a software package is centrally hosted and accessed by a SaaS company’s customers. Issues to be aware of include: As important as the foregoing issues are, one often overlooked […]

Read more about Worrying About SaaS Agreements and Cross-Border Data Transfers

FAQs About Legal Services for Social Media Influencers, Bloggers, and Online Content Creators

FAQs About Legal Services for Social Media Influencers, Bloggers, and Online Content Creators

Internet Law

If you are serious about your career as a social media influencer, blogger, and/or online content creator, you ARE going to need legal services at some point. Online creation is big business now, and big business means the need for legal services. The Internet and Social Media Attorneys at Revision Legal are here to help. […]

Read more about FAQs About Legal Services for Social Media Influencers, Bloggers, and Online Content Creators

Take it Down Act: Ban on “Revenge Porn” Goes National

Take it Down Act: Ban on “Revenge Porn” Goes National

Internet Law

Congress recently passed the Take It Down Act (“TIDA”), and the law was signed by the President in mid-May 2025. See AP media report here. Interestingly enough, “Take It Down” is an acronym for “Tools to Address Known Exploitation by Immobilizing Technological Deepfakes on Websites and Networks Act.” TIDA prohibits what is commonly called “revenge […]

Read more about Take it Down Act: Ban on “Revenge Porn” Goes National

Put Revision Legal on your side