St. Joseph trade secret attorneys Revision Legal, represent plaintiff and defendants in trade secret litigation. Through our office located in St. Joseph, Michigan, Revision Legal litigates trade secret issues throughout Southwest Michigan.
What Your Business Should Know About Trade Secrets
First, it is important to understand what law controls. Michigan has enacted the Michigan Uniform Trade Secrets Act (MUTSA). This law gives businesses the power to stop, or even prevent, the unauthorized release on business information.
Second, your business should understand what information constitutes a trade secret. Not all information within your business is protected by the MUTSA. In fact, the information that is protected is relatively narrow. For example, not all information that is considered “confidential” will be protected as a trade secret.
The formal, statutory definition is available at MCL 445.1902. In general, Michigan law defines a trade secret as information in a compilation, formula, program, or process that 1) is actively kept secret and 2) derives value from that secrecy.
Third, fitting the information of a particular case into the statutory definition can be difficult. Customer lists, customer data, and vendors lists, for example, may or may not be protectable trade secrets. For more detail, click here.
Fourth, how you treat your own information matters. For example, if you post customer lists on your website, you are not taking steps to protect that information. As a result, it will not be protected as a trade secret. The same applies for customer lists in your marketing materials and trade show materials.
If the information is readily available to the public, the MUTSA will not protect it as a trade secret.
Trade Secret Litigation
St. Joseph trade secret attorneys Revision Legal have experience litigating trade secret cases. If your business is facing the reality of an ex-employee joining a competing business, and you are concerned with the use of information your business spent time and money building, Revision Legal can help.
On the other hand, if you must defend a claim for the misappropriation of a trade secret, Revision Legal can advise you on potential liability and the strengths and weaknesses of the case.
To learn more, or to schedule a consultation with our trade secret attorneys, contact Revision Legal today by completing the contact form on this page or by calling 269-281-3908.
Misappropriation of Trade Secrets: The Legal Standard
Under MCL 445.1902(b), misappropriation of a trade secret occurs when someone acquires a trade secret through improper means, or discloses or uses a trade secret without consent after acquiring it under circumstances creating a duty of secrecy. Improper means under Michigan law include theft, bribery, misrepresentation, breach of a duty to maintain secrecy, and industrial espionage. In practice, the vast majority of St. Joseph trade secret cases involve a former employee or business partner who took confidential information when the relationship ended.
To prevail on a misappropriation claim in Michigan, a plaintiff must establish three elements: (1) the existence of a trade secret; (2) the defendant’s acquisition of the trade secret under circumstances giving rise to a duty of confidence; and (3) the defendant’s unauthorized use or disclosure of the trade secret. Courts undertake a detailed factual inquiry on each element, and trade secret litigation is inherently fact-intensive. The outcome often turns on the quality of the evidence — how the information was developed, how access was controlled, what agreements were in place, and exactly what the defendant did with the information.
Common Fact Patterns in St. Joseph Trade Secret Cases
Revision Legal handles trade secret disputes arising in a variety of business contexts in Southwest Michigan. The most common scenarios we encounter include:
- Departing employees — A key employee resigns and joins a direct competitor, bringing with them customer contact lists, pricing data, or proprietary processes that belong to the former employer. This is the single most common trade secret fact pattern and one where speed of response is critical.
- Business partner disputes — Two parties share confidential business information in the context of a potential joint venture, acquisition, or partnership. The relationship breaks down, and one party uses the disclosed information for their own benefit.
- Vendor or contractor misuse — A vendor or independent contractor with access to proprietary systems, formulas, or processes uses that information to compete with or undercut the business that shared it.
- Cyber theft — Employees or outsiders access computer systems without authorization and extract confidential business information. These cases often implicate both state trade secret law and the federal Defend Trade Secrets Act (DTSA), 18 U.S.C. § 1836.
The Defend Trade Secrets Act: Federal Protection
In 2016, Congress enacted the Defend Trade Secrets Act (DTSA), which for the first time created a federal civil cause of action for trade secret misappropriation. 18 U.S.C. § 1836. The DTSA does not preempt state law claims under the MUTSA — both can be pursued simultaneously. The DTSA uses a definition of trade secret substantially similar to the MUTSA’s, requiring that the owner have taken reasonable measures to keep the information secret and that the information derive independent economic value from its secrecy.
One significant advantage of the DTSA is its ex parte seizure provision. Under 18 U.S.C. § 1836(b)(2), a court may, in extraordinary circumstances, issue an order seizing property necessary to prevent the propagation or dissemination of the trade secret without prior notice to the defendant. This is an extraordinary remedy rarely granted, but it is available where, for example, a defendant has made clear an intent to immediately disclose or distribute misappropriated information. Revision Legal’s attorneys are experienced in both federal and state trade secret proceedings and can advise St. Joseph businesses on which forum and which claims provide the best strategic position.
Remedies Available to St. Joseph Businesses
When a trade secret has been misappropriated — or when misappropriation is threatened — the MUTSA and DTSA provide the following remedies:
- Injunctive relief — Courts may enter temporary restraining orders and preliminary and permanent injunctions to prevent actual or threatened misappropriation. MCL 445.1903; 18 U.S.C. § 1836(b)(3)(A). This is typically the first priority in an emergency trade secret situation.
- Actual damages and unjust enrichment — A plaintiff may recover both its actual losses and any unjust enrichment gained by the defendant that is not already captured in the actual loss calculation. MCL 445.1904.
- Exemplary damages — For willful and malicious misappropriation, courts may award up to twice the actual damages as exemplary damages. MCL 445.1904(2).
- Attorney’s fees — Reasonable attorney’s fees may be awarded in cases of willful misappropriation or bad-faith claims. MCL 445.1905.
Protecting Your St. Joseph Business Before a Dispute Arises
The time to protect your trade secrets is before they are stolen. Businesses with strong trade secret protection programs are better positioned both to prevent misappropriation and to succeed in litigation if it occurs. Revision Legal advises St. Joseph-area businesses on practical protective measures including:
- Auditing which business information qualifies as a trade secret and documenting the analysis;
- Restricting access to confidential information on a need-to-know basis and maintaining logs of who accesses what;
- Requiring employees, contractors, and business partners to sign robust non-disclosure agreements before accessing confidential information;
- Including enforceable confidentiality provisions in employment agreements, with clear post-termination obligations;
- Implementing IT security measures — encryption, access controls, activity monitoring — that demonstrate ongoing effort to maintain secrecy; and
- Conducting thorough employee exit procedures, including reminders of confidentiality obligations and retrieval of all company property.
Revision Legal’s St. Joseph trade secret attorneys represent both plaintiffs seeking to protect their business information and defendants facing trade secret claims. If your business is at risk — or if you have been served with a trade secret complaint — contact us immediately. Call 269-281-3908 or complete the contact form on this page for a confidential consultation.