Online Streaming: What Makes a Customer? featured image

Online Streaming: What Makes a Customer?

by John DiGiacomo

Partner

Revision Legal

Music-streaming services allow their subscribers to rent music through the Internet rather than purchase albums. Services such as Apple Music and Tidal charge a membership fee and often have exclusive music deals with certain artists. Other services, like Pandora and Spotify, allow users to subscribe for free and listen to music with occasional advertisements. Despite the free subscription, some consumers pay for commercial-free streaming, even though they aren’t able to download the music.

Pandora, in particular, allows subscribers to create playlists based on a musical genre or specific artist. However, users may not select specific songs. Rather, Pandora streams music and the listener can indicate whether they like or dislike each individual song that plays. Based on the listener’s selections, Pandora modifies the playlist to suit the listener’s preference.

Do Music Subscribers Have Privacy Rights?

Under the Preservation of Personal Privacy Act (PPPA), a person involved in the business of selling, renting, or lending sound recordings may not release information that indicates the customer’s identity. This includes the customer’s purchase, lease, rental, or borrowing of those recordings.

In 2011, Peter Deacon sued Pandora. He claimed that it violated the PPPA when it made his profile page available to the public and integrated the profile with his Facebook account. Deacon stated that because the profile included information about his music preferences, it violated his personal privacy. However, only a customer may claim a violation under the PPPA. Further, the act defines a customer as a person who purchases, rents, or borrows. The Court held that Deacon was not a customer, despite his use of Pandora for free music streaming, because both renting and borrowing often require an exchange of payment. Therefore, Deacon needed to have a paid subscription to claim a violation of the PPPA.

Internet-based services are becoming more widespread in today’s society. Consumers should be aware of how those services my affect their privacy. Chief Justice Young noted that Deacon’s case required applying a rarely used statute to new technology that did not exist at the time the statute was created, which brings up the question of whether this statute, among other privacy laws, should be amended to protect the users of internet-based technology.

For more information about privacy, contact Revision Legal’s team of experienced internet attorneys through the form on this page or call 855-473-8474.

 

Image courtesy of Flickr user g4ll4is

Extra, Extra!
Recent Posts

California: Retailers Must Warn That Digital Goods Can Be Taken Away

California: Retailers Must Warn That Digital Goods Can Be Taken Away

Internet Law

California Assembly Bill No. 2426, recently enacted into law, introduces significant amendments to the Business and Professions Code, specifically targeting consumer protection against false advertising in the realm of digital goods. This legislation, approved by the Governor on September 24, 2024, aims to address the misleading practices often associated with the sale of digital goods, […]

Read more about California: Retailers Must Warn That Digital Goods Can Be Taken Away

E-Commerce Package Protection May Violate Insurance Law

E-Commerce Package Protection May Violate Insurance Law

Internet Law

E-commerce business owners often look for ways to increase their cart size to in turn increase the revenue of their business. Many resort to adding package protection, a form of warranty or guaranty that a package will arrive undamaged. However, many of these package protection products may run afoul of state insurance law. E-commerce merchant […]

Read more about E-Commerce Package Protection May Violate Insurance Law

Challenges in Protecting Children’s Online Privacy: COPPA and TikTok

Challenges in Protecting Children’s Online Privacy: COPPA and TikTok

Internet Law

Protecting the privacy of children’s online personal data is complicated and challenging. The problems are made more difficult by the fact that, seemingly, children are happy to skirt and evade the various efforts made by online platforms to protect their privacy and by the fact that data collection businesses are happy if those efforts succeed. […]

Read more about Challenges in Protecting Children’s Online Privacy: COPPA and TikTok

Put Revision Legal on your side