What is Right to Repair? Lessons from Patent Law featured image

What is Right to Repair? Lessons from Patent Law

by John DiGiacomo

Partner

Patent

The right-to-repair movement has been in the news lately. Right-to-repair advocates argue that, if you buy a product, you should be allowed to repair it if it becomes nonfunctional. Further, companies should be required to provide manuals, instructions and tools — particularly software tools — that make repair possible. Companies are resistant to complying with requests for many reasons. Money is one reason, since if a product no longer functions, then consumers will have to buy another. Protecting trade secrets and intellectual property is another reason. Copyrights, trade secrets and patents protect the inner workings of devices like smartphones and tablets. Right-to-repair issues are, of course, not limited to electronics. With respect to farm machinery, automobiles and related products, there has been a long-running battle between manufacturers and consumers over the ability to repair the machines.

Interestingly enough, a few decades ago there was a similar right-to-repair fight with respect to patent law. Patent owners claimed that repairing a product was patent infringement. However, the courts eventually held that patent owners gave an implied license to their customers that allowed repair and refurbishment as long as the product was not completely rebuilt or reconstructed. One relatively famous case is Hewlett-Packard v. Repeat-O-Type Stencil, 123 F. 3d 1445 (Fed. Cir. 1997). That case held that it was NOT patent infringement for users to refill ink cartridges for use in Hewlett-Packard (“HP”) printers. HP owned the patents on the cartridges and argued that refilling them and adding new seals was a “reconstruction” of the product, not a “repair.” The court disagreed. It is likely that cases like Hewlett-Packard will be cited by courts when right-to-repair advocates are litigating these issues.

There has been good news for the right-to-repair movement lately. As reported here, the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) has voted to begin drafting new regulations that would ban manufacturers from having strict repair restrictions. Further, as reported elsewhere, the White House has officially backed the right-to-repair movement. giving verbal and legal support to the FTC. As further reported, Apple, Inc., will now begin offering parts, software tools and manuals to support repair of some of their products.

In related news, the Librarian of the Library of Congress has recently expanded the definition of “fair use” with respect to copyrights. Generally, copyright laws deem it infringement to “circumvent a technological measure that effectively controls access to” parts of a device where copyrighted material is located and access to the software. See 17 U.S.C. § 1201. But, the Librarian has stated that a “fair use” exception to this general rule exists when a user circumvents a security measure if the purpose is to repair or conduct maintenance on the device. This is welcome news for the right-to-repair movement since so many products now contain electronics and software. Previously, any attempt to access the software to repair the device or product put the user at risk of being sued for copyright infringement.

For more information, contact the trusted internet lawyers  and patent lawyers at Revision Legal at 231-714-0100.

Extra, Extra!
Recent Posts

FTC Adopts Final “Click to Cancel Rule”

FTC Adopts Final “Click to Cancel Rule”

Internet Law

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has issued final amendments to its trade regulation rule concerning negative option plans, also known as the “click to cancel rule.” This rule aims to address widespread deceptive practices that prohibit customers from cancelling services in the same manner in which they signed up. Here’s a detailed summary of the […]

Read more about FTC Adopts Final “Click to Cancel Rule”

Understanding Product Liability Law for Ecommerce Merchants

Understanding Product Liability Law for Ecommerce Merchants

Internet Law

Introduction Being an ecommerce merchant is hard; you have to keep an eye on your advertising spend, control your inventory, and make sure your customers are happy. Additionally, you also have to navigate a complex landscape of legal responsibilities. One of these areas, which is often overlooked, is product liability. Product liability law holds manufacturers, […]

Read more about Understanding Product Liability Law for Ecommerce Merchants

Understanding the Role of Internet Privacy Attorneys: Key Issues They Handle

Understanding the Role of Internet Privacy Attorneys: Key Issues They Handle

Internet Law

Introduction In our increasingly digital world, the significance of internet privacy is paramount. Internet privacy attorneys are essential in safeguarding the rights of individuals and organizations against various privacy-related challenges. This blog post delves into the key issues these attorneys address. Data Breaches and Cybersecurity Data breaches occur when sensitive information is accessed or disclosed […]

Read more about Understanding the Role of Internet Privacy Attorneys: Key Issues They Handle

Put Revision Legal on your side